Ever since that first patch that made the Feral tree useful for the first time (1.8 or so?) I was specced Feral more often than Resto. I specced Feral because my favorite mode of play is just soloing quests, farming stuff and testing out the newest version of my interface while chatting the time away. I do group but it is not my preferred style of play because of time constraints and “sudden-afk” problems – I hate to have to ditch people in the middle of something, so I only group when I am absolutely sure that the chance of an interrupt coming along is low.
So for most of BC I was a happy cat and sometime bear-tank or tree-healer. With the latest developments in druid specs I may yet spend my playtime as a Laser Chicken or Boomkek in Wrath. Here’s my analysis why and please bear with me to the end:
I am not the world’s greatest melee DPS. I specced DPS because it is the smart thing to do if you solo a lot. I don’t really enjoy DPSing in instances. Of two possible DPS specs Feral was the better choice because it had the added bonus of being able to tank and since there was a tank shortage for the longest time … Balance seemed like a waste. So Melee DPS and Tanking it was. But:
I think tanking is the most stressful of all the roles, because in degrees of failure, tank failure is the most epic and causes the fastest wipes – at least that’s what I felt like in instances. Also the tank is most often expected to lead the group it seemed to me and I am pretty casual in my knowledge of instances and bosses … so I often felt overwhelmed tanking. When I want to play to relax, I don’t tank an instance. And to tell the truth , mostly I do indeed play the game to relax.
I love healing instances. I really do like it. I like to hang back behind the group and be master over the life and death in the group. I like watching how fights unfold and throwing around my HoTs. I find healing much more relaxed than any of the other roles and I also think it’s what I do best. Of course a healer also depends on having good tanks around and right now I have plenty of those.
So now … I am facing a dilemma what to do with my 2 druids. Yashima(70) is definitely the main and Yáshimá(67) an alt, I want to level both to 80. Right now they are both Boomkeks and I am really indecided what to do in Wrath.
Here’s a list of the Druid facts relevant to my decision:
- Caster DPS aka Moonkin is finally a valid spec
- Melee DPS does not automatically include a great tanking spec anymore. This is the change that inspired this article: too many different Cat and Bear Talents. I fear I am not able to make a Feral spec that is both a good tank and good DPS.
- Swipe is an AoE tanking ability now
- Moonkin can use CC (Roots + Hibernate), Cat has a much harder time to do that
- With 4 valid tank classes there will be no “tank shortage” and one less reason to spec feral
There are also a few “unknowns”:
- So far no dual specs and it will probably take a while
- Melee DPS used to have a much harder time in fights: I remember the sigh that went through the group when we stood before Prince and there were a lot of Melees. I don’t really think this will change. Being close to the mobs is more dangerous than staying at a distance.
- How are Glyphs going to change respeccing? Are we going to change our glyphs when we respec?
- Tanking may however be less stressfull in Wrath or so several comments from the Blues on the forums seem to indicate (sorry don’t have a link to that right now)
- Those same comments seem to suggest that mana management for Healers may become more stressfull
- Concerning Gear: it seems to me like both Cat and Bear itemization and Tree and Moonkin itemization are getting more similar with a few differences but few enough to make collecting gear much easier. However this pairs “specs” in a certain way and I may want to specialize with both Druids. (This is worth a whole new article)
So this is what it looks like right now: to be a good tank now, I will need to spec explicitly for tanking. Before this being a good tank didn’t include respecs for me it was just an added bonus of speccing DPS. I am afraid this will no longer be the case.
I wonder how many druids will face the same dilemma. Before 3.0.2 there were a lot of Druid tanks out there because Feral was – and is – a great tree to spec into and being a tank was part of being the best DPS spec for druids.
Now there are two great DPS specs and neither includes being a tank. What will you do come Wrath? What about the casuals, what about the raiders? How will you spec: pure Caster DPS? Pure Healer? Melee DPS? Tank? A mix of Melee + Tank for leveling?
I am undecided …